Voice Module

Reviews

Previews

Features

Classic

Archive

Contact

Gallery


In Memory
Sean Pettibone

Review

Sonic's Ultimate Genesis Collection (Playstation 3)

With more than 40 titles ranging from Sonic's classic adventures, to Phantasy Star plus more obscure games like Dynamite Heady and Decap Attack, the collection offers a good overview of the 16-bit era. Unlike the last compilation, there are a few Sega Master System games unlockable this time around like Shinobi and Fantasy Zone in addition to a couple of arcade classics. The other major feature allows players to upscale the games to semi-HD quality using filters, which is a nice addition. Overall, Sonic's Ultimate Genesis Collection delivers exactly what you'd expect from a compilation of classic games.

It was just a couple of years ago that Sega released a compilation of their classic Genesis titles on the PS2, and the appearance of Sonic's Ultimate Genesis Collection seems initially to be a redundant cash-in on these old games. However, a closer inspection reveals that while there are a few repeat titles, the latest edition is a more complete and thorough compilation of Sega's golden age. Consider this to be the upgraded edition, where the first one had 28 games, this one has 40 and features more full rom sets to complete these series' original runs. For example, the original game only had the first two Streets of Rage games, while the PS3 edition has all three. As you might expect, Sonic plays a large role in the new compilation as well, with the first three adventures, plus Sonic & Knuckles and additional titles such as Sonic 3D Blast, Sonic Spinball making appearances. These aren't exactly the most uncommon titles to find, but its convenient to see all of them in one place. Of course, some players will probably bemoan missing games like Sonic CD, but the key to enjoying these games is appreciating what is included.

For example, Sonic's original outings single-handedly made Sega a force in the gaming world. What's surprising is how well they've held up over the years. These remain appealing games and its little wonder why the blue hedgehog remains one of the most iconic gaming mascots. The games are still fun despite the recent rough waters he's traversed over the past few years, and playing them again almost compensates players who suffered through the character's last couple of dreary comeback attempts. The original games seen here remain as charming and challenging as ever with their brilliant level designs and imaginative enemies making them as memorable and entertaining as ever. Of course, the package offers more than just Sonic. Players will also find other legendary Sega titles such as both Vectorman games, Ecco the Dolphin, All three Golden Axe games, Kid Chameleon, Gain Ground and Flicky to name a few. There's also a couple of lesser-known, obscure games such as Bonanza Bros, ESWAT, Fatal Labyrinth, Columns and Thunder Blade in the package to make for a more complete selection. Surprisingly, the title features many RPG's including the first two Shining Force games, Beyond Oasis and includes the first four installments in the legendary RPG series Phantasy Star, which alone makes the package worth the price of admission. Considering how much money they can fetch on auction sites, this makes a great value. The games cover a wide variety of genres and styles and many of them remain quite playable, showing the enduring appeal of classic 2D gameplay.

Oddly, you can't just play all of them out of the box and have to unlock the first SMS Phantasy Star installment in order to play it, which is annoying. This is one of the biggest drawbacks to the disc - some of the most appealing games need to be unlocked. This applies to a dozen different titles including to the arcade games, like Shinobi, Zaxxon, Altered Beast and Congo Bongo as well as most of the SMS titles in this release, which is quite annoying. Its doubly true since these games are the ones that most players will most likely want to play first. Some of the unlocking conditions aren't too bad, such as collecting the first chaos emerald in Sonic 1, there are some which are quite annoying and makes this frustrating. For example, having to beat the first level of Streets of Rage with all three characters in order to unlock Congo Bongo feels like a chore, and isn't fun. While you do get trophies for collecting these, its an annoying system. You also need to perform these tasks to view the interviews, which is another huge drawback. Whoever decided that making players unlock content they already paid for was a good idea made a bad choice. On the bright side, some of the interviews are quite interesting and entertaining, making the struggle to unlock them almost worth the effort. Ultimate Genesis Collection also includes a mini-museum for each game, usually consisting of a box scan and a brief description. It's an underwhelming experience in terms of presentation but it's somewhat acceptable overall.

The games themselves look about the same as they ever have, with the limitations of technology making them appear either charming or dated depending on your point of view. In this collection, however, players have the choice of playing them in their original aspect ratio in letterboxed form, or going for an enhanced presentation that stretches out the visuals to full 16:9 aspect ratio. The games look a little bit stretched out, but play well. You can also choose to put on a filtering effect which dulls the edges of the graphics. It's a kind of hit-or-miss with the filters, some games look slightly better while others just look blurry and out of focus, so it depends on which games you choose. Gamers who might have traded in or lost their original Genesis games will probably enjoy this one more than those who've continued to play these games on emulators or maintained a classic collection through the years. While the selection of games is decent, the developers made a bad decision in keeping many titles behind trophy-gates, which makes Sonic's Ultimate Genesis Collection appear less generous than it could have. Despite these annoyances, this is a decent selection of Genesis games that delivers a good selection of classic titles at a value price.

- Michael Palisano

Grade: B-

> Related Reviews

Sega Genesis Collection (PS2)
Samurai Shodown Anthology
(Wii)
King of Fighters Collection
(Wii)
Fatal Fury Anthology (PS2)